Skip to content

Contaminated site next door: what are the risks and what should you do?

Published on by Emphase Environnement

Old rusty tank partly buried in a field

A contaminated site nearby does not mean yours is contaminated. The risk depends on three things: the type of contaminant, the distance and, above all, the direction of groundwater flow, which carries contamination from one property to another. The approach is simple: read what the public registries say about the neighbouring site, check where it sits relative to yours, then have a professional assess the situation if doubt remains, before you buy, sell or refinance.

How to find out whether a neighbouring site is contaminated

Several public sources exist. None is complete on its own.

  • The Répertoire des terrains contaminés (contaminated sites registry, in French) of the Quebec Environment Ministry (MELCCFP). You can search by municipality, address or type of contaminant. The same files are shown on a map in the Repère GTC tool.
  • The registry of soil and industrial residue deposits (in French), which lists deposits inventoried by the Ministry since 1984.
  • The Federal Contaminated Sites Inventory, for sites under federal responsibility.
  • The land register. When a study carried out under the Environment Quality Act shows that the limit values are exceeded, a contamination notice must be registered (section 31.58). A decontamination notice can follow after the work (section 31.59).
  • The municipality. Section 31.68 of the Act requires every municipality to keep a public list of contaminated sites on its territory, based on those notices.

What the registry says, and what it doesn't

The provincial registry is useful, as long as you know its limits. The Ministry spells them out itself.

It is not exhaustive. It is a compilation of the cases brought to the Ministry's attention. An old garage closed forty years ago, with no study and no report, is not in it. Not being listed does not prove there is no contamination.

A site never leaves it. The Ministry states that no site is ever removed from the registry, even after it has been rehabilitated. A listed site may well have been decontaminated years ago. Read the entry: it shows the status of the rehabilitation.

There is a threshold. As a rule, a site is listed when its characterization showed soil contamination above criterion B of the Ministry's intervention guide, the equivalent of the Schedule I limit values of the Land Protection and Rehabilitation Regulation, which apply in particular to residential land.

The details are held regionally. The entry gives the contaminants and the medium affected, soil or groundwater. For more, you have to contact the Ministry's regional office.

The real risks for your property

Migration through groundwater

This is the main mechanism. Contaminants that reach the water table move with it, slowly, in the direction of flow. A contaminated site upgradient of yours deserves more attention than the same site downgradient or across a river.

Not all contaminants travel the same way. Metals in fill generally stay where they are. Gasoline, heating oil and some solvents move more with water. Soil type matters too: water flows faster through sand than through clay.

Vapours

Volatile compounds, like those in gasoline or some solvents, can rise from the soil as vapour. The question arises mainly when the contamination is directly under a building or very close to it.

Your well water

If you get your water from a private well, groundwater quality concerns you directly. This is the case where nearby contamination matters most.

Value and financing

Even without migration, the neighbourhood has a practical effect: a buyer or lender who sees a listed site close by will ask questions. For a commercial or multi-unit building, they will ask for a Phase 1, which looks precisely at neighbouring properties. See what your lender requires on the environmental side.

And often, no effect at all

It should be said too: in many cases, a contaminated site one or two hundred metres away has no consequence for yours. The contamination is confined to the original site, already removed, or located downgradient. The goal is not to worry about every listing, but to spot the ones that call for a check.

What the law says between neighbours

Quebec's Environment Quality Act contains two provisions worth knowing.

The duty to notify the neighbour (section 31.52). Whoever has custody of land contaminated above the limit values by a listed industrial or commercial activity must notify the neighbouring owner in writing and without delay as soon as they learn that the contaminants are at the property line, or that there is a serious risk of migration likely to compromise a use of water. A copy goes to the Minister. If you receive such a notice, keep it and ask for the study it is based on.

Protection for whoever suffers the migration (section 31.43). The Minister can order a remediation plan from whoever has custody of contaminated land. But not from a custodian who shows that the contaminants migrated from outside the property and are attributable to a third party. That still has to be demonstrated: a dated report, made before the purchase or as soon as the problem is found, is the best evidence.

Compensation for damage between neighbours is a civil law matter: consult a lawyer.

What to do, depending on your situation

You are thinking of buying

  1. Check the registries, for the property and for its neighbours. Prephase does it for you: for $45, you get a preliminary report in minutes that lists, within 300 m of the address, provincial and federal contaminated sites, Urgence-Environnement interventions, petroleum equipment, flood zones and wetlands, with a map. The report is for information only, has no legal value and does not replace a Phase 1. Its cost is credited if you then order a Phase 1 from Emphase.
  2. If something comes up, get a Phase 1. The professional examines the history of the site and its neighbours, aerial photos and topography, and concludes whether the neighbour is a real concern for the property.
  3. If the Phase 1 recommends it, a Phase 2 checks with samples, often near the property line on the neighbour's side. Our article on soil testing before buying land explains how to plan for it in the offer to purchase.

You already own the property

  • Read the neighbouring site's entry: contaminants, medium affected, rehabilitation status. A completed rehabilitation changes everything.
  • Do you have a well? Have your water analyzed by an accredited laboratory, asking for the parameters linked to the neighbour's contaminants.
  • Did you receive a written notice from a neighbour, or notice a hydrocarbon odour in the basement or in the water? Have the situation assessed without waiting. A report establishes the condition of your property and the origin of the contamination.
  • Planning to sell or refinance? Better to know the answer before the buyer or lender asks.

You are selling

Don't let the buyer discover the neighbour's listing at the last minute. A recent report concluding that the neighbouring site does not affect yours settles the question before it derails the sale.

In short

A contaminated site next door is information to check, not a verdict. Look at the rehabilitation status, the distance and the position relative to groundwater flow. If doubt remains, a Phase 1 answers the question without drilling.

To discuss it with a professional, request a free quote or call us at (514) 688-9747 in Montreal or (418) 520-9747 in Quebec City.

Free quote

Start your project with us today

Every project is unique. Tell us what you need and receive a clear, tailored, no-obligation quote.

Request a quote