Skip to content

Commercial loans: what your lender requires on the environmental side

Published on by Emphase Environnement

Stack of plans and technical documents on a moss-covered rock

For a loan secured by a commercial, industrial or multi-unit building, the lender almost always asks for a recent Phase 1 environmental site assessment (ESA), carried out under the CSA Z768-01 standard by an independent firm, that the lender can rely on itself. If that Phase 1 identifies a risk of contamination, the lender will want a Phase 2 before releasing the funds. The simplest approach is to know the lender's requirements before ordering the report, so you don't pay for it twice.

Why the lender cares about the soil

A lender doesn't finance land, it finances collateral. Three things worry it.

The value of the property. Contaminated land is worth less and is hard to resell. If the borrower defaults, the lender takes back an asset that is difficult to sell.

The ability to repay. Unexpected decontamination can swallow a company's room to manoeuvre. BDC tells the story of an entrepreneur who bought a property for cash without due diligence: when he needed financing for upgrades, the environmental assessment the lender required revealed contamination, and he paid more than $100,000 in remediation himself.

The law. Section 31.43 of Quebec's Environment Quality Act allows the Minister to order a remediation plan from whoever contaminated the land, but also from whoever has or had custody of it, as owner, tenant or otherwise. The Act provides defences, for example for a person who did not know of the contamination and could not have known of it given their duty of diligence. A Phase 1 done before the purchase is precisely the record of that diligence. The order is also served on the holders of rights registered in the land register, so on the mortgage lender, and a contamination notice is registered on the title.

As a result, in BDC's words: "Most lenders require an environmental assessment of commercial property."

Which properties are concerned

The request is close to systematic for:

  • commercial and industrial buildings, for purchases and refinancing alike;
  • multi-unit residential buildings;
  • vacant land intended for construction;
  • any property whose history or surroundings include a risky use: gas station, garage, workshop, dry cleaner, heating oil tank.

For a single-family home, the lender usually asks for nothing, unless there is a specific red flag such as an old buried heating oil tank or a property listed in a contaminated sites registry.

What the lender checks in the report

1. The standard followed

In Canada, the reference for a Phase 1 is the CSA Z768-01 standard. It sets the minimum content: review of historical records, site visit, interviews, report and conclusions. A report that does not follow it risks being rejected. Emphase's Phase 1 assessments follow this standard, and our reports are accepted by financial institutions and by CMHC.

2. The date of the report

A report describes the site at a given date. The Quebec Environment Ministry's site characterization guide (in French) states that a Phase I can be considered current for a maximum of one year, after which an update may be required. Each lender has its own rule, sometimes stricter. Before reusing the seller's report or one from a previous financing, ask your lender how old a report it will accept.

An update does not redo the whole study: it identifies the new activities that may have taken place on the site and on neighbouring properties since the original report.

3. Who can rely on the report

A report is prepared for a specific client. The lender wants to be able to rely on it too, so it asks to be named as an addressee, or to get a letter from the consultant allowing it to rely on the report, usually called a reliance letter. That is why a report the seller ordered for another buyer is not always enough.

Before hiring a firm, check what your lender requires on this point, then ask the firm whether it can meet it. It is easier to settle at the start than the day before closing.

4. Who did the study

The lender wants a firm independent of the seller and the broker, with qualified professionals. Some institutions keep a list of approved consultants or recommend some to their clients. Ask before you hire anyone.

5. The conclusion

This is what the credit analyst looks at first. They want an unambiguous conclusion: no environmental concern identified, or concerns named with a recommendation for a Phase 2. A vague report delays the file as much as a bad result.

What about CMHC?

For multi-unit buildings, many loans go through CMHC mortgage loan insurance, for example the MLI Select product. In that case, the approved lender puts the file together for CMHC and tells you which reports to provide, including the environmental report. Ask early, because the insurer's requirements come on top of the lender's.

If the Phase 1 recommends a Phase 2

That is not the end of the transaction. A Phase 1 does not prove that land is contaminated: it says there is a reason to check. The Phase 2 takes soil and groundwater samples at the targeted locations and has them analyzed in a laboratory.

Two possible outcomes:

  • The results meet the limits allowed for the land's use. The environmental question is settled and the financing proceeds.
  • The results exceed those limits. You then have numbers to negotiate with: a lower price, decontamination by the seller before the sale, or withdrawing the offer. As BDC puts it, the clean-up can become a condition of the sale, or the buyer may walk away.

Our article Phase 1, Phase 2, Phase 3: which assessment do you need? explains how the steps fit together.

Building the time into the offer to purchase

A common mistake is ordering the Phase 1 too late. A Phase 1 generally takes 2 to 4 weeks, depending on the site's complexity and access to records. If it leads to a Phase 2, add the drilling and laboratory analysis. BDC suggests that two months should be enough for a thorough environmental assessment.

Three reflexes:

  • make your offer conditional on an environmental assessment satisfactory to you and to your lender;
  • allow a due diligence period long enough for a Phase 2 if one becomes necessary;
  • order the Phase 1 as soon as the offer is accepted, without waiting for the lender's commitment letter.

Also ask the seller for any reports they already have. Even outdated ones speed up the historical research.

Refinancing and leasing too

A lender may ask for a new Phase 1 at refinancing, even if nothing has changed in your view: neighbouring uses may have changed and the old report has aged. This is the typical case for an update.

On the tenant side, BDC recommends that businesses whose activities could affect the environment get a baseline Phase 1 before signing a lease, so they are not held responsible later for contamination that was already there.

Five questions to ask your lender

Send them to your account manager or mortgage broker before hiring a firm:

  • Which standard do you require for the Phase 1?
  • How old can an existing report be, and is an update enough?
  • Do you have a list of approved consultants?
  • Who should the report be addressed to, and do you need a reliance letter?
  • Do you have other requirements, for example for a CMHC-insured building?

With these five answers, the firm can give you a report the lender will accept the first time.

Lenders, brokers and notaries

Are you helping a client with a transaction and need a report you can rely on? Emphase Environnement carries out Phase 1 assessments under the CSA Z768-01 standard everywhere in Quebec, all year round, and continues with Phase 2 and decontamination when needed, with no change of firm midway. Reach us through the quote page or call (514) 688-9747 in Montreal or (418) 520-9747 in Quebec City, and mention the closing date.

For a first screening before even ordering a study, Prephase produces a $45 preliminary report in minutes from the public registries around an address. It is for information only, has no legal value and does not replace a Phase 1; its cost is credited if a Phase 1 is then given to Emphase.

Free quote

Start your project with us today

Every project is unique. Tell us what you need and receive a clear, tailored, no-obligation quote.

Request a quote